Your idea should have stomped #433 #418 #407 #386 #383 #365 #347 #345 #310 #296 #281 #203 #146 #144 #38 Just going by case ideas not counting creativity,#432 should have stomped them all.
Hey, I like #418. A little over the top maybe, but the blend of complexity and attractiveness made for an excellent looking mod. As far as the guidelines go though, #281 hardly had a mod description. I doubt any changes will be made now that they've picked the top 30 though.